Substitute for Vanilla Extract

Need a substitute for vanilla extract? Here are 2 alternatives ranked by quality, with exact ratios for baking and cooking.

Alternatives

Vanilla Bean Paste

Excellent

Use 1:1

Thicker with visible seeds. Excellent premium swap. Same flavour intensity.

Vanilla Essence (imitation)

Acceptable

Use 1:1

Synthetic vanilla flavour. Less complex but much cheaper. Works for baking.

Need to convert vanilla extract?

Get cups to grams, tablespoons and more with our interactive converter.

Convert Vanilla Extract →

More Baking Substitutions

Substitute for Cocoa Powder2 options Substitute for Chocolate Chips1 options Substitute for Baking Powder1 options Substitute for Bicarbonate of Soda1 options Substitute for Golden Syrup3 options Substitute for Treacle2 options

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best substitute for vanilla extract?▼

The best substitute for vanilla extract is vanilla bean paste (1:1). Thicker with visible seeds. Excellent premium swap. Same flavour intensity.

Can I substitute vanilla bean paste for vanilla extract in baking?▼

Yes, vanilla bean paste can be used as a substitute for vanilla extract at a ratio of 1:1. Thicker with visible seeds. Excellent premium swap. Same flavour intensity.

Substitution ratios are approximate guidelines. Results may vary depending on the specific recipe. Always taste and adjust as needed.